Gas Vs. Gasless MIG Welder: Pros And Cons!

There is no rule of thumb when it comes to welding; there exists different types of MIG welders that can be used for versatile welding operations. The basic idea is to pay attention to differences between each type and thus to make out which one would be most appropriate to serve your desired purpose.

MIG welding is one of the easiest welding processes but it would only give you best results if technique is adopted appropriately with the right type of welder. The two main types include Gas MIG Welder (commonly termed as gas shielded welder) and Gasless MIG Welder (commonly termed as self-shielded welder).

In this page we will be discussing both the types along with their advantages and disadvantages.

Gas vs. Gassless MIG Welder:

As the name suggests, the gas MIG welder would need some external shielding gas for operation while the gasless welder doesn’t need any. The gasless MIG welder makes use of a flux cored wire that depends on a tubular wire feed that works continuously.

The gas shield that is needed to give protection and prevent oxidation is provided by vapor forming compounds in flux. Taking in to account pros and cons of each of these two types of MIG welders, you need to be able to choose the right type for a specific application.

Pros and Cons of each Type:

We will be discussing some factors based on which you can make your decision whether you find gas MIG welder more appropriate for your application or a gasless MIG welder.

Convenience of Use:

One of the premier factors that one considers while purchasing or using any tool is related to convenience. Without any doubts, a gasless MIG welder is most convenient to use. You will find a gasless welder lighter and portable to carry. Moreover you would not need to clean and shine material before welding.

Even if the surface that needs to be weld is rusted, has paint or is galvanized, you will be able to weld well through the surface with the aid of a gasless welder. The flux here enables you weld through such surfaces with ease. Thus for that purpose too, a gasless MIG welder is appropriate choice for industrial projects. There is no need for gas and thus there will be no need of a gas cylinder.

Use Outdoors:

A gasless MIG welder doesn’t need any gas for shielding and thus could be a nice option to use outdoors for welding. There is no need of an external gas tank with this type of MIG welder and thus you can easily use them on the move too.

Moreover for locations where weather gets extremely windy, gas MIG welder would not be appropriate for use as loss of gas will produce porosity in bead and thus would affect quality of weld. In light wind as well, you may need to struggle with the use of a gas shielded MIG welder. So for outdoors, a gasless MIG welder should be preferred for convenience of use.

Welding Material:

Another important aspect that enables you to make a right choice is material to be welded. A gasless MIG welder usually offers impressive strength and penetration however it depends upon technique and machine used for the purpose. Some of the welders would work even with thinnest pieces of metal whereas some won’t work well.

Welding Positions:

For applications that need out of position welding, a gas MIG welder would be suitable. For instance you need to weld vertically upwards, the flux cored wire shielded with gas would have a coating that would work well for solidifying the molten welded materials quicker to produce a shelf holding pool.

Welding Positions:

For applications that need out of position welding, a gas MIG welder would be suitable. For instance you need to weld vertically upwards, the flux cored wire shielded with gas would have a coating that would work well for solidifying the molten welded materials quicker to produce a shelf holding pool.

Fumes:

A gasless MIG welder produces more fumes however by wearing protection at all times during the process you can get protection from them.

Clarity of Welding Process:

One drawback of gasless MIG welder is that as soon as you weld the material, there appears a protective covering that bubbles up slag so you won’t be able to see actually what weld pool is doing.

As opposed to this, you can easily adjust the technique and speed of welding pool with the use of a gas MIG welder.

Conclusion

By having a look at all the details of advantages and disadvantages of both gas and gasless MIG welder, you can make out that the gasless MIG welder is a good option considering convenience of use and simple setup.

Whereas depending upon varied works you would do, you will be able to make out which type would be best? Many of the welders also consider and tell you that a gas MIG welder gives you exclusive quality of welding that you would appreciate in your work.

You can even opt for a welder that is capable of working as a gas and gasless welder and there are a number of machines available in market today offering features of both the designs by being a gas-gasless MIG welding machine. So identify your needs and choose an appropriate type of MIG welder that you believe will fit well in your requirements.

Click Now To Share!
Traci
 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments